ESPC Home | 1997-98 LAP* Book | Background | Legislators | PAC's | Legislation | LAP* Book Home

Accountability
Health and Human Needs
Justice System
K-12 Education
State Employees
Taxation and Revenue
Wildlife and Environment
Worker and Public Safety

SF 74: HEALTH INSURANCE - ADULT WELLNESS BENEFITS - 1997 General Session

Sponsor: Sen. Rich Cathcart (D-S6, Carpenter); co-sponsors Sen. Irene Devin (R-S10, Laramie); Sen. Carroll Miller (R-S19, Shell); Rep. Wayne Johnson (R-H9, Cheyenne); Rep. Clarene Law (R-H23, Jackson); Rep. George McMurtrey (R-H52, Gillette); Rep. Larry Meuli (R-H8, Cheyenne); Rep. Louise Ryckman (D-H60, Green River); Rep. Kathryn Sessions (D-H43, Cheyenne); Rep. Bill Stafford (R-H3, Chugwater)

SF 74 was an effort to improve health care and control costs by requiring insurance companies to cover pre-screening for early detection of illnesses such as (but not limited to) breast cancer, prostate cancer and cervical cancer.

SF 74 followed a similar bill (SF 44) in the 1996 budget session, which failed in Committee of the Whole in the House on a 28-32 vote after passing the Senate 19-10.

SF 74 required 80% minimum insurance coverage prior to deductibles for the first $200 of covered services (with 20% coinsurance by the insured), for a maximum benefit of $160 per calendar year.

Proponents of the bill argued that it would save lives and money by detecting diseases in their early stages, when treatment is more likely to succeed and is less expensive.

Opponents argued that the Legislature should not create mandates for insurance companies on what types of coverage to provide. They also argued that small businesses cannot afford higher premiums (despite evidence that avoiding catastrophic medical costs should keep premiums down).

The bill passed the Senate, 16-13 (1 excused), and was referred to the House Appropriations Committee, where it died on a 3-4 vote. The chair of the House Appropriations Committee, Rep. Rick Tempest, is an insurance agent, but did not declare a conflict of interest.

During the 1998 session, the Legislature passed a bill requiring individual and group insurance policies to disclose coverage for wellness benefits, but did not require such benefits.

The votes listed below are the Senate third reading (final passage) vote and the House Appropriations Committee vote.

A YES vote means the legislator supported mandatory insurance coverage for early disease detection.

A NO vote means the legislator opposed such coverage.

 

BIG HORN BASIN LEGISLATORS

Vote

S18

Sen. Hank Coe (R)

No

S19

Sen. Carroll Miller (R)

Yes

S20

Sen. Gerald Geis (R)

Yes

 

CASPER-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

S27

Sen. Gail Zimmerman (R)

No

S28

Sen. Keith Goodenough (D)

Yes

S29

Sen. Bill Hawks (R)

No

S30

Sen. Charles Scott (R)

Yes

 

CHEYENNE-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

S4

Sen. April Brimmer Kunz (R)

No

S5

Sen. Donald Lawler (R)

Yes

S6

Sen. Rich Cathcart (D)

Yes

S7

Sen. Guy Cameron (D)

Yes

S8

Sen. Jayne Mockler (D)

Yes

 

GILLETTE-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

S23

Sen. Larry Gilbertz (R)

No

S24

Sen. Dick Erb (R)

No

 

LANDER/RIVERTON-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

S25

Sen. John Vinich (D)

Excused

S26

Sen. Bob Peck (R)

No

 

NORTHEAST/EAST CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

S1

Sen. Bill Barton (R)

No

S2

Sen. Jim Twiford (R)

No

S3

Sen. Curt Meier (R)

No

 

SHERIDAN-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

S21

Sen. Tom Kinnison (R)

Yes

S22

Sen. John Schiffer (R)

No

 

SOUTH CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

S9

Sen. Vince Picard (R)

No

S10

Sen. Irene Devin (R)

Yes

S11

Sen. Bob Grieve (R)

No

 

SOUTHWEST WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

S12

Sen. Rae Lynn Job (D)

Yes

S13

Sen. Ray Sarcletti (D)

Yes

S14

Sen. Mark Harris (D)

Yes

S15

Sen. Greg Phillips (D)

Yes

 

WEST CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

S16

Sen. Delaine Roberts (R)

Yes

S17

Sen. Grant Larson (R)

Yes

 

HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE

Vote

Rep. Rick Tempest, Chair (R-H37, Casper)

No

Rep. Mike Baker (R-H28, Thermopolis)

No

Rep. Bill Bensel (D-H30, Sheridan)

Yes

Rep. Fred Parady (R-H17, Rock Springs)

Yes

Rep. Kathryn Sessions (D-H43, Cheyenne)

Yes

Rep. Marlene Simons (R-H1, Beulah)

No

Rep. Denny Smith (R-H25, Powell)

No


www.equalitystate.org
Copyright 1999, Equality State Policy Center