ESPC Home | 1997-98 LAP* Book | Background | Legislators | PAC's | Legislation | LAP* Book Home

Accountability
Health and Human Needs
Justice System
K-12 Education
State Employees
Taxation and Revenue
Wildlife and Environment
Worker and Public Safety

HJ 10: PARTIAL VETO AUTHORITY - 1998 Budget/Special Session

Sponsor: Rep. Bruce Hinchey (R-H36, Casper); co-sponsors Rep. Wende Barker (D-H45, Laramie), Rep. Eli Bebout (R-H55, Riverton), Rep. Bill Bensel (D-H30, Sheridan), Rep. Budd Betts (R-H22, Dubois), Rep. Bruce Burns (R-H51, Sheridan), Rep. John Hanes (R-H42, Cheyenne), Rep. Mike Massie (D-H13, Laramie), Rep. Tony Ross (R-H7, Cheyenne), Rep. Bill Stafford (R-H3, Chugwater), Rep. Rick Tempest (R-H37, Casper), Sen. Guy Cameron (D-S7, Cheyenne), Sen. Mark Harris (D-S14, Green River), Sen. Jayne Mockler (D-S8, Cheyenne), Sen. John Schiffer (R-S22, Kaycee)

During the 1997 special session on education, the Legislature enacted a bill establishing a new structure for the state’s public school financing system, and including appropriations related to the new system and the transition from the old to the new.

The Wyoming Constitution gives the governor the "power to disapprove of any item or items or part or parts of any bill making appropriations of money." Governor Jim Geringer vetoed parts of the special session bill dealing with the structure of the new school finance system -- not the appropriations.

The Legislature’s Management Council then voted to bring a "friendly" lawsuit against Gov. Geringer, asserting that he could veto only appropriations and therefore his vetoes of other parts of the bill were unconstitutional.

Just prior to the 1998 session, the Wyoming Supreme Court ruled in favor of Gov. Geringer’s position.

A number of legislators then sponsored HJ 10, which proposed to amend the Wyoming Constitution to limit the governor’s partial (line-item) veto authority only to general appropriations bills, not any bill containing an appropriation.

Joint resolutions proposing an amendment to the Wyoming Constitution must pass the Legislature by a two-thirds majority, and then be approved by a majority of the people voting in the next general election.

HJ 10 easily garnered the two-thirds majority vote from legislators, passing 53-7 in the House and 30-0 in the Senate.

The seven dissenting representatives were John Hines (R-H31, Gillette), Wayne Johnson (R-H9, Cheyenne), George McMurtrey (R-H52, Rozet), Carolyn Paseneaux (R-H38, Casper), Dorothy Perkins (R-H35, Casper), Peg Shreve (R-H24, Cody), and Bob Tanner (R-H57, Casper).

However, Gov. Geringer then vetoed the bill.

The Legislature may override a veto with a two-thirds majority. The first vote takes place in the house where the bill originated. Despite the 53-7 margin when HJ 10 first passed the House, the veto override attempt fell short, 31-28 (1 excused).

The vote listed below is the House vote to override Gov. Geringer’s veto of HJ 10.

A YES vote means the representative favored overriding the governor’s veto of a proposed constitutional amendment limiting the governor’s line-item veto authority only to general appropriations bills.

A NO vote means the legislator opposed overriding the governor’s veto.

 

 BIG HORN BASIN LEGISLATORS

Vote

H24

Rep. Peg Shreve (R)

No

H50

Rep. Pat Childers (R)

No

H25

Rep. Denny Smith (R)

Yes

H26

Rep. Chas. Hessenthaler (R)

Yes

H27

Rep. Ray Harrison (R)

No

H28

Rep. Mike Baker (R)

Yes

 

 CASPER-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

H35

Rep. Dorothy Perkins (R)

No

H36

Rep. Bruce Hinchey (R)

Yes

H56

Rep. Pat Nagel (R)

Excused

H57

Rep. Bob Tanner (R)

Yes

H37

Rep. Rick Tempest (R)

No

H59

Rep. Nancy Berry (D)

No

H38

Rep. Carolyn Paseneaux (R)

Yes

H58

Rep. Ann Robinson (D)

Yes

 

 CHEYENNE-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

H7

Rep. Tony Ross (R)

No

H41

Rep. Mac McGraw (D)

Yes

H8

Rep. Larry Meuli (R)

No

H42

Rep. John Hanes (R)

No

H9

Rep. Wayne Johnson (R)

No

H10

Rep. Pete Anderson (R)

Yes

H11

Rep. Wayne Reese (D)

No

H43

Rep. Kathryn Sessions (D)

Yes

H12

Rep. Leo Garcia (D)

Yes

H44

Rep. Floyd Esquibel (D)

No

 

 GILLETTE-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

H31

Rep. John Hines (R)

No

H52

Rep. George McMurtrey (R)

No

H32

Rep. Jeff Wasserburger (R)

No

H53

Rep. Nick Deegan (D)

No

 

 LANDER/RIVERTON-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

H33

Rep. Harry Tipton (R)

N

H54

Rep. Cale Case (R)

Yes

H34

Rep. Frank Philp (R)

Yes

H55

Rep. Eli Bebout (R)

Yes

 

 NORTHEAST/EAST CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

H1

Rep. Marlene Simons (R)

Yes

H2

Rep. Ross Diercks (D)

Yes

H5

Rep. Jim Hageman (R)

No

H6

Rep. Jim Anderson (R)

No

H3

Rep. Bill Stafford (R)

Yes

H4

Rep. Roger Huckfeldt (R)

Yes

 

 SHERIDAN-AREA LEGISLATORS

Vote

H29

Rep. Rick Badgett (R)

No

H51

Rep. Bruce Burns (R)

Yes

H30

Rep. Bill Bensel (D)

Yes

H40

Rep. Douglas Osborn (R)

No

 

 SOUTH CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

H13

Rep. Mike Massie (D)

Yes

H45

Rep. Wende Barker (D)

No

H14

Rep. Phil Nicholas (R)

No

H46

Rep. Tom Rardin (R)

Yes

H15

Rep. Tony Rose (R)

No

H47

Rep. Teense Willford (R)

Yes

 

 SOUTHWEST WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

H16

Rep. Kenilynn Zanetti (D)

Yes

H48

Rep. Jack Steinbrech (R)

No

H17

Rep. Fred Parady (R)

No

H60

Rep. Louise Ryckman (D)

Yes

H18

Rep. John Eyre (R)

No

H39

Rep. Chris Boswell (D)

Yes

H19

Rep. Peggy Rounds(D)

Yes

H49

Rep. Ken Decaria (D)

Yes

 

 WEST CENTRAL WYOMING LEGISLATORS

Vote

H20

Rep. Louie Tomassi (R)

Yes

H21

Rep. Randall Luthi (R)

Yes

H22

Rep. Budd Betts (R)

Yes

H23

Rep. Clarene Law (R)

No


www.equalitystate.org
Copyright 1999, Equality State Policy Center