ESPC Home | 1997-98 LAP* Book | Background | Legislators | PAC's | Legislation | LAP* Book Home

Accountability
Health and Human Needs
Justice System
K-12 Education
State Employees
Taxation and Revenue
Wildlife and Environment
Worker and Public Safety

HB 193: BIAS CRIMES - 1997 General Session

Sponsor: Rep. Rick Badgett (R-H29, Sheridan); co-sponsors Rep. Bill Bensel (D-H30, Sheridan), Rep. Mike Massie (D-H13, Laramie), Rep. Pat Nagel (R-H56, Casper), Rep. Harry Tipton (R-H33, Lander) and Sen. Jayne Mockler (D-S8, Cheyenne)

SF 123: BIAS CRIMES - 2 - 1997 General Session

Sponsor: Sen. Keith Goodenough (D-S28, Casper)

HB 193 and SF 123 (identical bills) represented the third attempt at enactment of a bias crimes bill.

Like their predecessors, HB 193 and SF123 provided for enhanced penalties for crimes committed if the victim was intentionally selected in whole or in part due to the perpetrator's belief or perception regarding the race, color, disability, sexual orientation, national origin or ancestry of the victim or the owner or occupant of damaged property (regardless of whether the perpetrator's belief was correct).

Proponents of the bills supported them primarily as an attempt to send a message that Wyoming will not tolerate attacks sparked by prejudice.

Opponents came from two directions: Those who agreed with the philosophy of the bills but saw existing penalties as adequate; or those who saw the bills as a sanctioning of homosexuality or special treatment for certain groups.

HB 193 was passed 7-2 by the House Judiciary Committee, but died on General File in the House (was not brought up for debate).

SF 123 was referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, which held the bill until it was too late to be considered on the floor, and then voted on a technical motion to indefinitely postpone consideration of SF 123.

The votes listed below are the House Judiciary Committee vote on HB 193, and the Senate Judiciary Committee vote to indefinitely postpone SF 123.

In the House committee, a YES vote means the representative favored enhanced penalties for bias crimes.

In the House committee, a NO vote means the representative opposed enhanced penalties for bias crimes.

 

HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE

Vote

Rep. Harry Tipton, Chair (R-H33, Lander)

Yes

Rep. Wende Barker (D-H45, Laramie)

Yes

Rep. Nick Deegan (D-H53, Gillette)

No

Rep. Randall Luthi (R-H21, Freedom)

Yes

Rep. Pat Nagel (R-H56, Casper)

Yes

Rep. Phil Nicholas (R-H14, Laramie)

Yes

Rep. Ann Robinson (D-H58, Casper)

Yes

Rep. Tony Rose (R-H15, Rawlins)

No

Rep. Jeff Wasserburger (R-H32, Gillette)

Yes

 

Senate Committee: Motion to Indefinitely Postpone SF 123

In the Senate committee, a YES vote means the senator opposed the bill, or thought the vote irrelevant since it was too late to consider the bill further.

In the Senate committee, a NO vote means the senator favored considering the bill, even though that was no longer possible.

 

SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE

Vote

Sen. April Brimmer Kunz, Chair (R-S4, Cheyenne)

Yes

Sen. Keith Goodenough (D-S28, Casper)

No

Sen. Carroll Miller (R-S19, Shell)

Yes

Sen. Greg Phillips (D-S15, Evanston)

Yes

Sen. Vince Picard (R-S9, Laramie)

Yes


www.equalitystate.org
Copyright 1999, Equality State Policy Center