|
HB 124: Eminent Domain – 2
2007 General Session
Sponsor: Joint Agriculture, Public Lands and Water Resources Interim Committee
HB 124 was the second attempt in two years to revise Wyoming’s laws
governing the use of eminent domain to acquire private property in the state.
Property may be condemned and taken by eminent domain for a variety of specific
uses that are for the greater good of the citizenry (i.e., power line rights
of way, transportation corridors, etc.), as well as for beneficial public use.
HB 124 somewhat strengthened protections for landowners in eminent domain
cases. It allowed for better compensation for landowners and established reclamation
and restoration requirements for all property acquired by eminent domain. It
required specific written notice to property owners of intended condemnation
actions before entry upon the land for any purpose could occur, and required
good faith negotiations for reasonable compensation.
Condemnors must make an initial written offer to purchase the property before
commencing a condemnation action, which must include an estimate of fair market
value of the property.
Condemnees must make reasonable and diligent efforts to negotiate in good
faith with the condemnor, including responding in a timely manner (within 65
days) to offers to purchase.
HB 124 limited condemnation authority of municipalities for urban renewal,
and eliminated the maximum amount on relocation expenses for a displaced farm,
organization or small business (previously capped at $10,000).
Landowners and other supporters of HB 124 argued that they don’t have
enough protections and rights under the state’s current eminent domain
laws, and that HB 124 would be a more balanced and fair approach.
Opponents maintained that current law has worked well, and they felt that
changing it might hinder needed projects or make them more expensive.
The House passed HB 124, 56-4. The Senate passed the bill, 25-4 (1 excused).
The votes listed below are the House and Senate third reading (final passage)
votes. A YES vote means the legislator wanted to make change eminent domain
laws to strengthen the rights of landowners and to limit condemnation authority
of municipalities for urban renewal. A NO vote means the legislator did not
want to make the changes contained in this bill.
LINK TO LSO HEA 0081 (engrossed version of HB 124) House 3rd Reading
|
| Bighorn Basin Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 18 |
Hank Coe (R) |
|
| H 24 |
Colin M. Simpson (R) |
Yes |
| H 50 |
Pat Childers (R) |
Yes |
| S 19 |
Ray Peterson (R) |
|
| H 25 |
Alan Jones (R) |
Yes |
| H 26 |
Elaine Harvey (R) |
Yes |
| S 20 |
Gerald E. Geis (R) |
|
| H 27 |
Debbie Hammons (D) |
Yes |
| H 28 |
Lorraine Quarberg (R) |
Yes |
|
| Casper-Area Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 27 |
John Barrasso (R) |
|
| H 35 |
Roy Cohee (R) |
Yes |
| H 36 |
Liz Gentile (D) |
Yes |
| S 28 |
Kit Jennings (R) |
|
| H 56 |
Tom Walsh (R) |
Yes |
| H 57 |
Thomas A. Lockhart
(R) |
Yes |
| S 29 |
Drew Perkins (R) |
|
| H 37 |
Steve Harshman (R) |
Yes |
| H 59 |
Mary Meyer Gilmore
(D) |
Yes |
| S 30 |
Charles K. Scott (R) |
|
| H 38 |
Bob Brechtel (R) |
Yes |
| H 58 |
Lisa Shepperson (R) |
Yes |
|
| Cheyenne-Area Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 4 |
Tony Ross (R) |
|
| H7 |
Doug Samuelson (R) |
Yes |
| H 41 |
Ken Esquibel (D) |
Yes |
| S 5 |
Bob Fecht (R) |
|
| H 8 |
Lori Millin (D) |
Yes |
| H 42 |
Pete Illoway (R) |
Yes |
| S 6 |
Wayne H. Johnson (R) |
|
| H 9 |
Dave Zwonitzer (R) |
Yes |
| H 10 |
Rodney "Pete" Anderson
(R) |
Yes |
| S 7 |
Kathryn Sessions (D) |
|
| H 11 |
Mary Throne (D) |
Yes |
| H 43 |
Dan Zwonitzer (R) |
Yes |
| S 8 |
E. Jayne Mockler (D) |
|
| H 12 |
Amy Edmonds (R) |
Yes |
| H 44 |
Floyd A. Esquibel (D) |
Yes |
|
| Gillette-Area Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 23 |
John Hines (R) |
|
| H 31 |
Thomas E. Lubnau II
(R) |
Yes |
| H 52 |
Sue Wallis (R) |
No |
| S 24 |
Michael Von Flatern
(R) |
|
| H 32 |
Timothy Hallinan (R) |
No |
| H 53 |
Erin Mercer (R) |
Yes |
|
| Lander/Riverton-Area
Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 25 |
Cale Case (R) |
|
| H 33 |
W. Patrick Goggles
(D) |
Yes |
| H 54 |
Del McOmie (R) |
Yes |
| S 26 |
Robert A. Peck (R) |
|
| H 34 |
Frank Philp (R) |
No |
| H 55 |
David Miller (R) |
Yes |
|
| Northeast/East Central
WY Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 1 |
Charles Townsend (R) |
|
| H 1 |
Mark Semlek (R) |
Yes |
| H 2 |
Ross Diercks (D) |
Yes |
| S 2 |
Jim Anderson (R) |
|
| H 5 |
Matt Teeters (R) |
Yes |
| H 6 |
Dave Edwards (R) |
Yes |
| S 3 |
Curt Meier (R) |
|
| H 3 |
Deborah Alden (R) |
Yes |
| H 4 |
Edward A. Buchanan
(R) |
Yes |
|
| Sheridan-Area Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 21 |
Bruce Burns (R) |
|
| H 29 |
Jerry Iekel (R) |
Yes |
| H 51 |
Rosie Berger (R) |
Yes |
| S 22 |
John Schiffer (R) |
|
| H 30 |
Jack Landon Jr. (R) |
Yes |
| H 40 |
Mike Madden (R) |
Yes |
|
| South Central WY
Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 9 |
Mike Massie (D) |
|
| H 13 |
Jane Warren (D) |
Yes |
| H 45 |
Kevin A. White (R) |
Yes |
| S 10 |
Phil Nicholas (R) |
|
| H 14 |
Kermit C. Brown (R) |
No |
| H 46 |
Jim Slater (R) |
Yes |
| S 11 |
Bill Vasey (D) |
|
| H 15 |
George Bagby (D) |
Yes |
| H 47 |
William Steward (R) |
Yes |
|
| Southwest WY Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 12 |
Rae Lynn Job (D) |
|
| H 48 |
Marty Martin (D) |
Yes |
| H 16 |
Pete Jorgensen (D) |
Yes |
| S 13 |
John Hastert (D) |
|
| H 17 |
Bernadine Craft (D) |
Yes |
| H 60 |
Bill Thompson (D) |
Yes |
| S 14 |
Stan Cooper (R) |
|
| H 18 |
Allen Jaggi (R) |
Yes |
| H 39 |
Stan Blake (D) |
Yes |
| S 15 |
Ken Decaria (D) |
|
| H 19 |
Owen Petersen (R) |
Yes |
| H 49 |
Saundra Meyer (D) |
Yes |
|
| Central WY Legislators |
1/26/2007 |
| S 16 |
Pat Aullman (R) |
|
| H 20 |
Kathy Davison (R) |
Yes |
| H 21 |
Dan Dockstader (R) |
Yes |
| S 17 |
Grant C. Larson (R) |
|
| H 22 |
Monte Olsen (R) |
Yes |
| H 23 |
Keith Gingery (R) |
Yes |
|
| Senate 3rd Reading
|
| Bighorn Basin Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 18 |
Hank Coe (R) |
Yes |
| H 24 |
Colin M. Simpson
(R) |
|
| H 50 |
Pat Childers (R) |
|
| S 19 |
Ray Peterson (R) |
Yes |
| H 25 |
Alan Jones (R) |
|
| H 26 |
Elaine Harvey (R) |
|
| S 20 |
Gerald E. Geis (R) |
No |
| H 27 |
Debbie Hammons (D) |
|
| H 28 |
Lorraine Quarberg
(R) |
|
|
| Casper-Area Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 27 |
John Barrasso (R) |
Yes |
| H 35 |
Roy Cohee (R) |
|
| H 36 |
Liz Gentile (D) |
|
| S 28 |
Kit Jennings (R) |
No |
| H 56 |
Tom Walsh (R) |
|
| H 57 |
Thomas A. Lockhart
(R) |
|
| S 29 |
Drew Perkins (R) |
Yes |
| H 37 |
Steve Harshman (R) |
|
| H 59 |
Mary Meyer Gilmore
(D) |
|
| S 30 |
Charles K. Scott
(R) |
Yes |
| H 38 |
Bob Brechtel (R) |
|
| H 58 |
Lisa Shepperson (R) |
|
|
| Cheyenne-Area Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 4 |
Tony Ross (R) |
Yes |
| H7 |
Doug Samuelson (R) |
|
| H 41 |
Ken Esquibel (D) |
|
| S 5 |
Bob Fecht (R) |
Yes |
| H 8 |
Lori Millin (D) |
|
| H 42 |
Pete Illoway (R) |
|
| S 6 |
Wayne H. Johnson
(R) |
Yes |
| H 9 |
Dave Zwonitzer (R) |
|
| H 10 |
Rodney "Pete" Anderson
(R) |
|
| S 7 |
Kathryn Sessions
(D) |
Yes |
| H 11 |
Mary Throne (D) |
|
| H 43 |
Dan Zwonitzer (R) |
|
| S 8 |
E. Jayne Mockler
(D) |
Yes |
| H 12 |
Amy Edmonds (R) |
|
| H 44 |
Floyd A. Esquibel
(D) |
|
|
| Gillette-Area Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 23 |
John Hines (R) |
Yes |
| H 31 |
Thomas E. Lubnau
II (R) |
|
| H 52 |
Sue Wallis (R) |
|
| S 24 |
Michael Von Flatern
(R) |
Yes |
| H 32 |
Timothy Hallinan
(R) |
|
| H 53 |
Erin Mercer (R) |
|
|
| Lander/Riverton-Area
Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 25 |
Cale Case (R) |
Yes |
| H 33 |
W. Patrick Goggles
(D) |
|
| H 54 |
Del McOmie (R) |
|
| S 26 |
Robert A. Peck (R) |
Excused |
| H 34 |
Frank Philp (R) |
|
| H 55 |
David Miller (R) |
|
|
| Northeast/East
Central WY Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 1 |
Charles Townsend
(R) |
Yes |
| H 1 |
Mark Semlek (R) |
|
| H 2 |
Ross Diercks (D) |
|
| S 2 |
Jim Anderson (R) |
Yes |
| H 5 |
Matt Teeters (R) |
|
| H 6 |
Dave Edwards (R) |
|
| S 3 |
Curt Meier (R) |
Yes |
| H 3 |
Deborah Alden (R) |
|
| H 4 |
Edward A. Buchanan
(R) |
|
|
| Sheridan-Area Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 21 |
Bruce Burns (R) |
No |
| H 29 |
Jerry Iekel (R) |
|
| H 51 |
Rosie Berger (R) |
|
| S 22 |
John Schiffer (R) |
Yes |
| H 30 |
Jack Landon Jr. (R) |
|
| H 40 |
Mike Madden (R) |
|
|
| South Central WY
Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 9 |
Mike Massie (D) |
Yes |
| H 13 |
Jane Warren (D) |
|
| H 45 |
Kevin A. White (R) |
|
| S 10 |
Phil Nicholas (R) |
Yes |
| H 14 |
Kermit C. Brown (R) |
|
| H 46 |
Jim Slater (R) |
|
| S 11 |
Bill Vasey (D) |
No |
| H 15 |
George Bagby (D) |
|
| H 47 |
William Steward (R) |
|
|
| Southwest WY Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 12 |
Rae Lynn Job (D) |
Yes |
| H 48 |
Marty Martin (D) |
|
| H 16 |
Pete Jorgensen (D) |
|
| S 13 |
John Hastert (D) |
Yes |
| H 17 |
Bernadine Craft (D) |
|
| H 60 |
Bill Thompson (D) |
|
| S 14 |
Stan Cooper (R) |
Yes |
| H 18 |
Allen Jaggi (R) |
|
| H 39 |
Stan Blake (D) |
|
| S 15 |
Ken Decaria (D) |
Yes |
| H 19 |
Owen Petersen (R) |
|
| H 49 |
Saundra Meyer (D) |
|
|
| Central WY Legislators |
2/22/2007 |
| S 16 |
Pat Aullman (R) |
Yes |
| H 20 |
Kathy Davison (R) |
|
| H 21 |
Dan Dockstader (R) |
|
| S 17 |
Grant C. Larson (R) |
Yes |
| H 22 |
Monte Olsen (R) |
|
| H 23 |
Keith Gingery (R) |
|
|
|
|